APPENDIX J.
BUDGET SPEECH DELIVERED BY HON. F.C. ALDERDICE, PRIME MINISTER, ON THURSDAY, 29th JUNE, 1933. (continued)
Fiscal Year 1933-34.
I proceed now to the
budget for the financial year beginning on 1st July next; and I will first read
to the Committee the figures which show the estimated expenditure of the different
Departments of the Government for the year.
Finance .................................................. 837,302
Secretary of State .................................. 57,270
Public Welfare ........................................ 905,362
Public Health .......................................... 271,800
Justice .................................................... 459,971
Education ................................................ 500,000
Agriculture and Mines ........................... 60,642
Marine and Fisheries ............................ 363,826
Post and Telegraphs ............................... 741,063
Customs ................................................. 414,840
Public Works ........................................... 588,612
War Pensions .......................................... 548,690
Assessor .................................................. 13,687
Labour ..................................................... 1,540
5,764,605
Interest on Public Debt ........................... 5,200,000
$10,964,605
I have certain comments to
make on these figures, but I will begin by saying that each item of expenditure, of
which each of these totals is composed has been scrutinised with the utmost care.
I hope and believe that, apart from circumstances which it is impossible to foresee
at the present time, it will not be necessary to ask for supplemental votes during
the course of the year. On the other hand, it would be a matter of extreme
difficulty, and indeed in my view impracticable, to carry on the proper
administration of the country, even at a minimum level as at present, by an
expenditure less than that which is set down under the head of each
Department.
In the case of interest on
the Public Debt, the sum estimated is $5,200,000. This total takes account of the
premium in respect to those coupons which are payable in New York; and it also
includes the additional amount compared with the Estimates for the previous year
which, on the present level of exchange, will be required to purchase sterling in
order to cover coupons payable in London.
I have given particularly
serious thought to the estimates for Public Welfare and Public Health. Great
reductions have been made in the cost of these Services during the past twelve
months. I have some hopes that further reductions can still be made; but the
situation at the present time is somewhat complicated by the fact that this
Government, at the beginning of the financial year 1932-33, took over a large
arrears of accounts from the previous administration; and although these have
now been paid, this has only been done at the cost of certain postponements in the
case of accounts since incurred. It is the object of the Government that there
shall remain no accounts outstanding by the end of the year now under
construction.
In the estimate for Public
Welfare is included the sum of $500,000 for able-bodied relief. As I have said,
the corresponding estimate for the year 1932-33 was of $50,000 only, a sum far too
small to take care of accounts which had already been incurred still less to
provide for the continuance of the system of relief already established, which it
was impossible to terminate at short notice. The great proportion of the sum of
$500,000 in the Estimates for this year is for the purpose of liquidating
outstanding accounts incurred under this system; the remainder we shall use as poor
relief in order to deal, on a minimum scale, with proved cases of necessity and
destitution as they arise.
In connection not only
with able-bodied relief, but with the Welfare and Health votes generally, I wish
to emphasize, in the strongest terms, the extreme necessity that for the future the
population of this country must be taught not to rely, as they have done for so
long in the past, upon the expectation of financial assistance and subvention from
the Government in the case of every difficulty, of however small a nature, which is
liable to befall them. During the last decade, and indeed longer, this mistaken
system of what I may call paternalism has, most unfortunately, done much to sap the
initiative of our citizens and to bring them to the frame of mind in which they
look upon Government aid as not only available as a right to which they are
undoubtedly entitled. This is not merely an incorrect view of the functions of
Government; it is a canker which is eating out the hearts of our people, and is a
grave menace to the proud spirit of independence on which Newfoundland has been
built up in the past. From the budgetary point of view it has only been possible
for this aid to be provided at the cost of a continual excess of annual expenditure
over annual revenue, and the resulting necessity for raising loans in order to
cover these deficits. This practice cannot, and must not, be continued. The only
possibility of a real and lasting revival of prosperity in this country depends
upon the realization by every member of the population that the qualities of
self-help and self-reliance are not a very precious possession, but are
indispensable qualities for ensuring the future welfare and independence both of
the individual and of the Dominion.
During the last
administration, two Departments of the Government, namely, that of Agriculture and
Mines and that of Marine and Fisheries, were combined under one Minister. This
appeared to me at the time a retrograde measure, and I gave an undertaking that
upon this Government coming into office they would proceed to the reconstitution
of each of these Departments as a separate entity. This has now been done; and has
also been done at a reduction in cost compared with that of the two Departments
when they were combined. It seems to me indisputable that, if the management of
these Departments is to be efficient, each one must have at its head a man of
proved experience in the matters in which the Department is concerned, who is
capable of taking a direct and considerable personal share in the Department's
administration and in the constructive solution of the problems with which both
our agricultural and our fishery industries are confronted at the present time.
Lines have now been laid down for a constructive agricultural policy. Further, I
have confidence that the provisions of the Salt Codfish Act, which has recently
become law, will ensure the co-operation between every section of the fishing
industry which I am sorry to say has been sometimes lacking in the past, but is
indispensable if we are to regain and maintain our position in the markets of the
world. The Committee knows, I expect, how near to my heart is the satisfactory
working of the provisions which the passing of this Act has brought into force.
When all is said and done, it is upon the fishing industry that the prosperity of
the Dominion primarily and nearly exclusively demands; and, if I know our
countrymen, I do not think that my appeal for willing and whole-hearted support in
the restoration and progressive improvement of this industry will fail.
With a view to furthering
the fishing industry during the present season, I am arranging that a sum shall be
included in the Estimates for providing outfits and similar necessaries for a
number of men of reliable standing who would otherwise not be able to proceed to
the fishery; these advances to be repaid, either by the transfer to the Government
of fish, or in cash, at the end of the season. The Government also proposes to
award prizes in some cases for fish of first-class quality and curing; as to which
further details will be issued later.
There appears in the
Estimates for the first time a heading for the Department of Labour. As the
Committee is aware, this Department was established upon my Government taking
office a year ago, and its establishment was recently confirmed by the House.
In the view of the Government, the results which are being achieved by the
Department amply justify the small expenditure involved.
In regard to the Education
Vote, it is unfortunately necessary that for this year it should be maintained at a
total not exceeding $500,000, that is to say, the sum to which it was reduced last
fall from the sum of $700,000 voted in last year's budget. The necessity for
maintaining this low figure is a most unpleasant one, but it is dictated by the
present and immediately prospective financial situation. I am glad to acknowledge
gratefully the services rendered in difficult circumstances by the fine body of men
and women who constitute the teaching profession of this country, and to undertake
that restoration at any rate in part of the decreases in salaries which have
inevitably been made will be one of the first considerations to which the
Government will apply themselves upon an improvement in the financial outlook.
At the same time, however, I think it cannot be denied that the present system of
teachers' pensions, as distinguished from salaries, is framed on somewhat too
generous lines, and I ought to say that I have in mind, not just at the present
time, but in the not too distant future, a decrease in the scale of contributions
now supplied to the pension fund by the Exchequer, which it appears to me can
properly be made. In this reference to Education I would like for a moment to
speak in my other capacity as President of the Bureau of Education, and to take
the opportunity of recording that I am by no means satisfied that the educational
curriculum at present in force, combined with the present system of annual
examinations, is entirely in accord with the needs of the children of the country
and the employment in which it is hoped they will find themselves when their
education is completed. I am hoping that changes will be introduced which will
bring the present system into more intimate relation with the country's
requirements.
|